The task of trying to represent another person in any form
and any medium will always fail.
Even representation of oneself can go horribly
wrong. There is no way to set oneself apart from the knowledge and experience
that a person has gain throughout their life. It is not possible, and we gain
more of both everyday through our interactions with the world. The problem with
trying to represent anyone other than yourself is actually in the wording. The
problem is that everyone is an other. No two people are the same and no two
people have the same perception of the world. These two differences lead to two
major problems with representation, generalization and alienation. We
understand who we are by understanding who we are not and why, which alienates
everyone. Generalization causes misrepresentation because even if something is
true about the vast majority there is no way that it is true for all. There are
always going to be outliers even when thinking about social cultural norms. It
is not possible to encompass everyone, so instead of always trying to identify
with a group that will then be misrepresented and offend; we need to realize
that even among similarities there are also differences. Every person has a different
perception, so which one is accurate? Are any of them accurate? Maybe for that
one person at that one time it was accurate but in a global scale probably not.
Even the most earnest attempts at objectivity are always going to have the faintest
tinge of subjectivity. In the documentary people of Western Culture were
interviewed and in class we discussed whether we were being represented in the
documentary and my personal answer is no. I understand that these interviews
were supposed to reveal some truth about our culture’s mindset and attitude
toward other cultures but do I identify on a person level with the
interviewees, no. I understand that there make be other people like him, I can
see how it is possible for him to have those opinions and say what he said. Do
I always agree? No, but I also know who I am and where I am in relation
everything. I wouldn’t get offended because I understand that there is always
an angle and there is always something that someone else wants me to see. Even the
lens of a documentary is subjective, there is a goal, and endpoint, and a spin.
There always is. Just like there are two sides to every story, sometimes they
match up but more often they do not.
No comments:
Post a Comment
Note: Only a member of this blog may post a comment.