I remember watching Good Copy Bad Copy in my WEPO class my
first semester here and how much I learned from it. When it comes to the
creativity and making something your own work, the question that is constantly
asked is: is this truly an original? Everyone has some sort of creativity about
them that they would love to share with the rest of the world, but how do we
make ourselves different without looking getting ideas from others who have
inspired us from the past? Does doing this make the creation we had in mind not original? People have often admitted
to being inspired others and their works, does that mean that we shouldn’t
pursue the idea we had in mind? In the documentary, one perfect example of this
is the DJ Girl Talk. His music essentially takes samples from other famous
artists and he remixes them together to make a song. This generation is almost
known for its reinvention of the art that we see on a daily basis. Whether it
be an old song remixed with a modern day song as Girl Talk does, or by taking a
moving image from a movie or show and writing a caption on it (also known as
GIF). If we were to apply the copyright law to everything we try and create,
there wouldn’t be many things created at all.
Another example is that of DJ
Danger Mouse. His project, which was remixing The Beatle’s White Album and rapper Jay-Z’s The
Black Album, was a huge hit in 2005. He called his album, ironically, The Grey Album, and once people started
to get a hold of his tracks, it went viral. Besides the fact that the DJ
created this himself, the actual music and lyrics technically were not his own,
therefore leaving him to receive no money from the selling of his album at all.
Having shared these songs through the Internet it was too late and it had been
shared to countless amounts of people. As said previously, if one were to look
at this from a lawyers perspective, they might agree and say this is
infringement and not original. However to the DJ and the fans he obtained after
this, they might say otherwise. He decided one day to make this a project of
his. He sat down and thought of an idea to remix and mash-up two albums that
are well known all over the world. Personally, this is creativity at its
finest, and people like DJ Danger Mouse as well as Girl Talk are simply trying
to let their creativity be known.
The Internet allows for people to
send, receive and look up anything they want to at the click of a button. If
its one thing people need to truly comprehend is that society is evolving into
easier and faster things. Because of this, it is obviously much easier to
obtain information than it was 150 years ago when people would go to the public
library instead. As I stated before with the example of the DJ’s, their goal in
mind is not to make a sham out of the artists that they are using, they are
simply trying to share with the rest of the world their creativity. Although
some artists do in fact find it offensive that others might be obtaining
coverage and even money for their creations with songs that they themselves
have created; they also must understand that they are trying to achieve the
same thing they did before they became a celebrity.
Ultimately this ongoing debate with
copyright might never be subject to change. We might always be under scrutiny
about what we have or what we plan to create due to the fact that it might be
“original” but one thing I do believe that must be understood is the fact that
we, as creators, must never stop trying to change, and we must continue to try
and show the world what we feel is important to share. People deserve to show
their talents and creativity to the world, who are we to tell them that they
can’t?
I am fully on board with your perspective of this documentary. What came to my mind while watching it was also the question of: is anything truly an original? Did the Beatles and Jay-Z not have inspiration for their music? I would believe so, and I believe they would tell you that they did if they were (could be) asked. In my response on the video, I did not mention DJ Danger Mouse, and I am happy that you brought it up in yours. Around minute 10, while talking about "The Grey Album" it is said, "...but it was far too late. Everyone had it, it was an instant classic." A classic. Woah. How, if it's not an original, can someone call this song a classic? I agree that it was a classic, that is was an original. No one else had thought to mash up genre's like this. In Miller, she talks about the "internal dynamic" that is needed for a genre to exist. Jay-Z's words flowed with the Beatles' beat. They had an "internal dynamic" which I believe led to Danger Mouse introducing a new genre for the first time. I couldn't have said it better when you said, "Personally, this is creativity at its finest..." So why keep people from their creativity? The Beatles publishing company had a problem with this album. Not Jay-Z, not the surviving Beatles artists, but the company (if I could use Bold in a response, company would be in Bold). Creativity is being squashed in Western society in order to give multi-billion dollar companies even more money. I'm with you Kayla, let talent be free to create.
ReplyDelete